Year | Name | School | Pts | Opponent |
| | | *playoff | |
2024 | Jalil Bethea | Wood | 36 | LaSalle |
| Kevin Rucker | Bonner | 34 | LaSalle |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | 34 | Egan |
| Aasim Burton | O'Hara | 33 | Judge |
| Nick Parisi | LaSalle | 33 | Wood |
| Kevair Kennedy | Judge | *33 | Wood |
| Zane Conlon | Devon | 32 | Carroll |
| Larenzo Jerkins | NG | 32 | Judge |
| Kevin Rucker | Bonner | 31 | NG |
| Aasim Burton | O'Hara | 31 | Wood |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | 31 | Ohara |
| Deuce Ketner | Bonner | 30 | Devon |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | 30 | SJ Prep |
| Luca Foster | Carroll | *30 | NG |
2023 | Jalil Bethea | Wood | 40 | SJ Prep |
| Rob Wright | NG | *36 | Carroll |
| Darren Williams | Ryan | 31 | Judge |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | 31 | NG |
| Zion Stanford | West | 31 | Egan |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | 31 | West |
| Rob Wright | NG | 30 | Wood |
| Jalil Bethea | Wood | *30 | SJ Prep |
2022 | Laquan Byrd | Judge | 37 | O'Hara |
| Moses Hipps | Carroll | 35 | NG |
| Daniel Skillings | Roman | 34 | Judge |
| Daniel Skillings | Roman | 31 | Judge |
| Luke Boyd | Ryan | 31 | Judge |
| Zion Stanford | West | 31 | SJ Prep |
| Daniel Skillings | Roman | 31 | O'Hara |
2021 | Jimmy King | SJ Prep | 36 | Bonner |
| Anquan Hill | Carroll | 32 | Ryan |
| Jimmy Casey | Lansdale | 30 | Judge |
| Hysier Miller | Ng | 30 | Wood |
| Jimmy King | SJ Prep | 30 | Carroll |
| Khalil Farmer | Roman | 30 | O'Hara |
| Daniel Skillings | Roman | 30 | McDevitt |
| Malik Edwards | Bonner | 30 | O'Hara |
2020 | Lynn Greer | Roman | 37 | Bonner |
| Rahsool Diggins | Wood | *35 | Roman |
| Jalen Duren | Roman | 34 | Wood |
| Justice Williamss | Roman | 32 | Wood |
| Jalen Duren | Roman | 30 | West |
| Trevor Wall | Prep | *30 | Carr |
2019 | Isaiah Wong | Bonner | 44 | N-G |
| Isaiah Wong | Bonner | 34 | O'Hara |
| Hakim Hart | Roman | 33 | O'Hara |
| Shane Dooley | Judge | 32 | O'Hara |
| Rahsool Diggins | Wood | 32 | O'Hara |
| Isaiah Wong | Bonner | 31 | C-E |
| Chris Ings | N-G | 31 | Carroll |
| Chris Ings | N-G | 30 | Wood |
| Sean Stokes | C-E | 30 | Devon |
| Mike Perretta | Bonner | 30 | Prep |
2018 | Tom Quarry | Judge | 39 | C-E |
| Andrew Funk | Wood | 35 | Roman |
| Patrick Robinson | C-E | 33 | Judge |
| Tyree Pickron | Wood | 32 | West |
| Isaiah Wong | Bonner | *32 | O'Hara |
| Patrick Robinson | C-E | 31 | West |
| Patrick Robinson | C-E | 30 | La Salle |
| Antwuan Butler | O'Hara | 30 | Wood |
| Seth Lundy | Roman | 30 | Carroll |
| Seth Lundy | Roman | 30 | Wood |
2017 | Patrick Robinson | C-E | 42 | Roman |
| Marc Rodriguez | Judge | 34 | West |
| Marc Rodriguez | Judge | *32 | Ryan |
| Quade Green | N-G | 33 | Bonner |
| Quade Green | N-G | 30 | Lansdale |
| Quade Green | N-G | 30 | Wood |
| Quade Green | N-G | 30 | Ryan |
| Jaye'Lyn Peebles | O'Hara | 40 | La Salle |
| Jaye'Lyn Peebles | O'Hara | 30 | Carroll |
| Izaiah Brockington | Ryan | *31 | Wood |
| Collin Gillespie | Wood | 42 | N-G |
| Collin Gillespie | Wood | *33 | Ryan |
2016 | Ryan Daly | Carroll | 33 | N-G |
| Ryan Daly | Carroll | *30 | Wood |
| Quade Green | N-G | *31 | Ryan |
| Zane Martin | N-G | *30 | Ryan |
| LaPri McCray-Pace | C-E | 33 | Wood |
2015 | Derrick Jones | Carroll | 30 | Ryan |
| Chris Clover | Prep | 37 | La Salle |
| Chris Clover | Prep | 30 | Bonner |
| Izaiah Brockington | Ryan | 32 | C-E |
| Luke Connaghan | Wood | 32 | N-G |
2014 | Tyrell Long | McDevitt | 34 | O'Hara |
| Tyrell Long | McDevitt | 33 | West |
| Tyrell Long | McDevitt | 33 | Bonner |
| Andrew Louden | O'Hara | 32 | Ryan |
| Tyrell Long | McDevitt | 31 | C-E |
| Ja'Quan Newton | N-G | 30 | Ryan |
| Chris Clover | Prep | 32 | N-G |
2013 | Amar Stukes | La Salle | 33 | Prep |
| Rashann London | Roman | 30 | Judge |
| Pat Smith | Wood | 30 | C-E |
2012 | Yosef Yacob | Carroll | 30 | West |
| Jamal Nwaniemeka | C-E | 37 | West |
| Jamal Nwaniemeka | C-E | 36 | Bonner |
| Jamal Nwaniemeka | C-E | 30 | Lansdale |
| Miles Overton | Prep | 30 | La Salle |
| Steve Vasturia | Prep | 31 | Judge |
| Steve Vasturia | Prep | 31 | La Salle |
| Pat Smith | Wood | 34 | West |
2011 | Juan'ya Green | Carroll | *39 | Prep |
| Juan'ya Green | Carroll | *30 | N-G |
| Lamin Fulton | N-G | 30 | Roman |
| Lamin Fulton | N-G | 30 | Prep |
| Joe Getz | Wood | 41 | West |
2010 | Ike Robinson | C-E | 42 | Carroll |
| Ike Robinson | C-E | 30 | Lansdale |
| Mike Barr | Lansdale | 31 | K-K |
| Tony Chennault | N-G | 31 | Dougherty |
2009 | Rakeem Brookins | Roman | 31 | N-G |
| Brendan Stanton | Lansdale | 38 | Dougherty |
| Brendan Stanton | Lansdale | 31 | C-E |
| Brendan Stanton | Lansdale | 30 | West |
2008 | Bob Zanneo | Judge | 31 | Dougherty |
| Bob Zanneo | Judge | 30 | La Salle |
| Maalik Wayns | Roman | 34 | West |
| Jim Mower | Prep | 30 | N-G |
| Jim Mower | Prep | *30 | Roman |
2007 | Jeff Jones | Bonner | 41 | N-G |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 36 | West |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 31 | Prep |
| Scoop Jardine | N-G | 32 | Prep |
| Rob Hollomon | West | 30 | N-G |
2006 | Adam Van Zelst | C-E | 30 | Judge |
| Vinny Simpson | Dougherty | 31 | C-E |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 31 | West |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 30 | O'Hara |
| Chris Mayo | West | 30 | K-K |
2005 | Derrick Graff | Bonner | 36 | K-K |
| Derrick Graff | Bonner | 34 | Prep |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 34 | Roman |
| Jeff Jones | Bonner | 30 | N-G |
2004 | Tom Amenta | K-K | 32 | West |
| Amarildo Matos | K-K | 38 | Bonner |
| Amarildo Matos | K-K | 32 | West |
| Rob Latimer | West | 30 | Roman |
| Marshall Taylor | West | 31 | Prep |
| Marshall Taylor | West | 30 | Roman |
2003 | DeSean White | Dougherty | 31 | McDevitt |
| DeSean White | Dougherty | 31 | McDevitt |
| Steve Wolf | Judge | 30 | McDevitt |
| Mark Zoller | Prep | *31 | Dougherty |
| Joe Mullin | Ryan | 31 | McDevitt |
| Amarildo Matos | K-K | 34 | Bonner |
2002 | Mike Spadafora | Wood | 30 | C-E |
| Andrew Holland | C-E | 34 | North |
| Andrew Holland | C-E | 30 | Dougherty |
| Donnie Welte | North | 32 | McDevitt |
| Ryan Rich | K-K | 35 | West |
| Ryan Rich | K-K | 33 | Carroll |
| Charron Fisher | Roman | 32 | Neumann |
| John Griffin | Prep | 31 | Carroll |
2001 | Mike Cram | North | 30 | La Salle |
2000 | Walt Pinkas | C-E | 32 | North |
| Wayne Bishop | McDevitt | 34 | Ryan |
| Fran Grandieri | O'Hara | *31 | Carroll |
| Fran Grandieri | O'Hara | 31 | Bonner |
| Jamar Stokes | Prep | 30 | Carroll |
| Jamar Stokes | Prep | 30 | K-K |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 34 | O'Hara |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 33 | Prep |
| Nate Lewis | West | 31 | Roman |
| Nate Lewis | West | 30 | Prep |
1999 | Ashley Howard | Bonner | 41 | K-K |
| Ashley Howard | Bonner | 35 | Prep |
| Ashley Howard | Bonner | 31 | O'Hara |
| Ashley Howard | Bonner | 30 | Roman |
| Chas Bailey | Neumann | 31 | Carroll |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 41 | K-K |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 38 | Neumann |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 33 | Bonner |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 31 | West |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 31 | Roman |
| Kasim Holloman | Prep | 31 | Carroll |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 41 | Carroll |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 38 | K-K |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 35 | Prep |
| Eddie Griffin | Roman | 31 | Neumann |
1998 | Scott Fremont | Bonner | 31 | Neumann |
| Dennis Moran | Bonner | 37 | Prep |
| Ashley Howard | Prep | 31 | K-K |
| Rasual Butler | Roman | 36 | O'Hara |
| Rasual Butler | Roman | 33 | Carroll |
| Rasual Butler | Roman | 32 | Bonner |
| Rasual Butler | Roman | 32 | K-K |
| Rasual Butler | Roman | 31 | Carroll |
| Anthony Starace | Ryan | 38 | McDevitt |
| Anthony Starace | Ryan | 32 | Wood |
| Anthony Starace | Ryan | 32 | C-E |
| Tim Whalen | Wood | 31 | Ryan |
1997 | Joe Meade | La Salle | 31 | McDevitt |
| Joe Meade | La Salle | 30 | Ryan |
| Ryan Presson | McDevitt | 32 | La Salle |
| Ryan Presson | McDevitt | 31 | Dougherty |
| Ryan Presson | McDevitt | 31 | La Salle |
| John Ashmore | West | 32 | Roman |
| Jasmine "Jazz" Williams | West | 33 | Carroll |
1996 | Mike Sigall | North | 30 | Ryan |
| Martin Ingelsby | Carroll | 30 | Bonner |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 36 | Neumann |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 35 | Prep |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 33 | O'Hara |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 33 | Bonner |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 32 | West |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 31 | K-K |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 31 | Prep |
| Donnie Carr | Roman | 30 | West |
1995 | Tim Anderlonis | Bonner | 33 | Prep |
| Jack Horgan | La Salle | *32 | Ryan |
| Jack Horgan | La Salle | 32 | North |
| Greg Klein | O'Hara | 30 | Neumann |
1994 | Tim Erb | La Salle | 37 | McDevitt |
| Rashid Bey | Neumann | 35 | Prep |
| Rashid Bey | Neumann | 30 | Roman |
| Dennis Comey | North | 30 | La Salle |
| Ed Woehlcke | Ryan | 32 | Dougherty |
1993 | Tom Tobin | Carroll | 33 | Prep |
| Danny Oldfield | Judge | 30 | Egan |
| Joe Harvey | North | 39 | Egan |
| Marc Jackson | Roman | 31 | Neumann |
| Sean Brennan | Wood | 32 | McDevitt |
| Dan Kiss | Wood | 37 | Dougherty |
1992 | Cuttino "Cat" Mobley | Dougherty | 37 | Kenrick |
| Cuttino "Cat" Mobley | Dougherty | 30 | McDevitt |
| David Neeld | Kenrick | 30 | Wood |
| Will Scott | Neumann | 34 | West |
| Levan Woodard | Neumann | 33 | Prep |
| Neil McGee | Prep | 34 | West |
| Neil McGee | Prep | 32 | Neumann |
| Neil McGee | Prep | 31 | Bonner |
| Kyle Locke | Roman | *39 | Dougherty |
| Kyle Locke | Roman | 35 | West |
| Scott Galloway | West | 32 | Roman |
| Chris McShane | West | 31 | St. James |
| Chris McShane | West | 30 | St. James |
1991 | Pat McCormick | Prep | 31 | West |
| Bernard Jones | Roman | 32 | St. James |
| Joe Miller | St. James | 39 | Prep |
| Rob Wharton | West | 33 | Prep |
1990 | Bernard Jones | Roman | *30 | La Salle |
| Kevin Smith | West | 33 | Roman |
| Kevin Smith | West | 31 | Carroll |
1989 | Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 32 | West |
| Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 30 | Carroll |
| Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 30 | St. James |
| Alan Watkins | Roman | 33 | Carroll |
| Jeff Cooney | St. James | 33 | West |
1988 | Brian Daly | Bonner | 35 | West |
| Brian Daly | Bonner | 30 | Carroll |
| Brian Daly | Bonner | *30 | North |
| John Tripodi | Neumann | 31 | O'Hara |
| John Tripodi | Neumann | 31 | West |
| Jim Schultice | North | 31 | Dougherty |
| Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 37 | Carroll |
| Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 32 | Carroll |
| Eddie Malloy | O'Hara | 30 | Roman |
| Mike Christian | Prep | 35 | Roman |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 41 | Prep |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 39 | Carroll |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 37 | Neumann |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 36 | Prep |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 34 | Roman |
1987 | Tom Dunn | Carroll | 33 | Prep |
| Tom Dunn | Carroll | 30 | St. James |
| Ed Minogue | Egan | 32 | North |
| John O'Connell | McDevitt | 33 | Kenrick |
| Mike O'Hara | O'Hara | 38 | Roman |
| Monroe Blakes | West | 34 | Roman |
1986 | Barry Bekkedam | Carroll | 41 | St. James |
| Barry Bekkedam | Carroll | 38 | West |
| Barry Bekkedam | Carroll | 37 | Neumann |
| Mike Carfagno | Kenrick | 30 | McDevitt |
| Ernest Pollard | Roman | 32 | Prep |
1985 | Steve Benton | Neumann | 31 | West |
| Mark Stevenson | Roman | 34 | Carroll |
| Mark Stevenson | Roman | 30 | West |
| John Rankin | West | 33 | Roman |
| John Rankin | West | 32 | Neumann |
1984 | Rodney Blake | Bonner | *30 | West |
| Dave Duda | Kenrick | 32 | Egan |
| Brian Leahy | Kenrick | 30 | Ryan |
| Mike McCarron | North | 37 | La Salle |
| Fran Ciliberti | Ryan | 37 | North |
| Mark Stevenson | Roman | 30 | Bonner |
1983 | Manny Carlis | Carroll | 30 | O'Hara |
| Brian Leahy | Kenrick | 35 | Dougherty |
| Hugh Coleman | North | 32 | Kenrick |
| Fran Ciliberti | Ryan | 31 | Wood |
| Jimmy Pee | St. James | 34 | Prep |
1982 | Kenny Dailey | Dougherty | 35 | Judge |
| Kenny Dailey | Dougherty | 31 | Wood |
| Kenny Dailey | Dougherty | 31 | Egan |
| Chip Greenberg | La Salle | 35 | Wood |
| Chip Greenberg | La Salle | 30 | Ryan |
| Keith Coleman | Prep | 30 | St. James |
| Mike Palumbo | Ryan | 33 | La Salle |
| Mike Palumbo | Ryan | 32 | Dougherty |
1981 | Jim Bolger | Kenrick | 36 | McDevitt |
| Jim Bolger | Kenrick | 33 | North |
| Jim Bolger | Kenrick | 31 | Ryan |
| Jim Bolger | Kenrick | 30 | Ryan |
| Chris O'Brien | La Salle | 30 | McDevitt |
| Troy Robertson | McDevitt | 32 | North |
| Troy Robertson | McDevitt | 31 | Ryan |
| Bob Rossi | North | 32 | Kenrick |
| Bob Rossi | North | 31 | McDevitt |
| Glenn Welton | Roman | 41 | Prep |
| Mike Palumbo | Ryan | 30 | La Salle |
| John McHugh | St. James | 30 | Carroll |
1980 | Jerry "Jake" Sutton | Dougherty | 34 | McDevitt |
| Jerry "Jake" Sutton | Dougherty | 30 | Kenrick |
| Lonnie McFarlan | Roman | 30 | Carroll |
1979 | Terry "Doc" Watson | Dougherty | 34 | North |
| Terry "Doc" Watson | Dougherty | 34 | Egan |
| Marty Campbell | Neumann | *32 | Roman |
| Dave Kerins | O'Hara | 31 | Bonner |
| Lonnie McFarlan | Roman | 31 | Prep |
1978 | Frank Pfanders | Kenrick | 30 | La Salle |
| Derrick Joynes | Neumann | 32 | West |
| Reggie Jackson | Roman | 41 | St. James |
| Reggie Jackson | Roman | 37 | Neumann |
| Reggie Jackson | Roman | 34 | Carroll |
| Reggie Jackson | Roman | 34 | Prep |
| Reggie Jackson | Roman | 33 | St. James |
| Donny Dodds | St. James | 33 | O'Hara |
| Jeff Hunter | West | 30 | Prep |
| Angelo Reynolds | West | 32 | Neumann |
1977 | Fran McCaffery | La Salle | 40 | Ryan |
| Bill Walter | Neumann | 31 | O'Hara |
| Joe Schoen | North | 38 | La Salle |
| Joe Schoen | North | 35 | McDevitt |
| Joe Schoen | North | 30 | Egan |
| Kevin Fitzpatrick | Ryan | 35 | McDevitt |
| Kevin Fitzpatrick | Ryan | 34 | Dougherty |
| Kevin Fitzpatrick | Ryan | 33 | McDevitt |
| Kevin Fitzpatrick | Ryan | 31 | La Salle |
| Richard Furr | West | 32 | O'Hara |
1976 | Ed Callan | Dougherty | 31 | McDevitt |
| Lawrence Reid | Dougherty | 42 | Egan |
| Lawrence Reid | Dougherty | 36 | Egan |
| Lawrence Reid | Dougherty | 32 | Wood |
| Jim "Mo" Connolly | Judge | 32 | La Salle |
| Bob Convey | Judge | 30 | McDevitt |
| Matt Mihalich | La Salle | 35 | Egan |
| Joe Boback | North | 37 | Wood |
| Mike Curley | O'Hara | 31 | St. James |
| Donny Dodds | Prep | 35 | Neumann |
| Michael Brooks | West | 46 | Bonner |
| Michael Brooks | West | 37 | St. James |
| Michael Brooks | West | 35 | Prep |
| Michael Brooks | West | 33 | St. James |
| Michael Brooks | West | 31 | Prep |
1975 | Joe Kurtz | North | 30 | Egan |
1974 | Paul Terrell | Dougherty | *30 | North |
| Don Hobson | North | 43 | McDevitt |
| Don Hobson | North | 30 | Dougherty |
| Don Hobson | North | 30 | Dougherty |
1973 | Terry Kehoe | Kenrick | 33 | North |
| Barry Brodzinski | North | 35 | Dougherty |
| Barry Brodzinski | North | 30 | Kenrick |
| Steve Vassalotti | Prep | 31 | Roman |
| Tim McKinney | St. James | 30 | Bonner |
1972 | Ed Stefanski | Bonner | 34 | Prep |
| Mike Stack | Bonner | 31 | Prep |
| Mike Stack | Bonner | 30 | Prep |
| Ron Newman | Dougherty | 31 | McDevitt |
| Jerry Gallagher | Egan | 30 | McDevitt |
| Bud Elsesser | Judge | 31 | North |
| Bud Elsesser | Judge | 31 | Ryan |
| Rick Hogan | La Salle | 32 | Wood |
| Rick Hogan | La Salle | 31 | Egan |
| Barry Brodzinski | North | 39 | La Salle |
| Mike Arizin | O'Hara | 34 | Prep |
| Maurice "Mo" Howard | Prep | 33 | ST More |
| Ron Schott | St. James | 34 | Prep |
1971 | Mike MacDonald | Bonner | 31 | Prep |
| Steve Wiley | La Salle | 30 | Wood |
| Maurice "Mo" Howard | Prep | 31 | West |
| Bill Truskey | Prep | 30 | Neumann |
| John Beecroft | Roman | 31 | St. James |
1970 | John Jablonski | Prep | 31 | Carroll |
1969 | Joe Cafferky | Bonner | 33 | ST More |
| Ed Hastings | Bonner | 32 | Neumann |
| Mike Dwyer | Carroll | 34 | ST More |
| Mike Dwyer | Carroll | 31 | St. James |
| Mike Dwyer | Carroll | 30 | West |
| Bill "Bear" Banks | Dougherty | 31 | La Salle |
| Bob Haas | McDevitt | 32 | Dougherty |
| Tom Ingelsby | O'Hara | 31 | ST More |
| Al Grenfell | ST More | 33 | Carroll |
| Al Grenfell | ST More | 30 | St. James |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 45 | St. James |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 34 | Prep |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 32 | Neumann |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 31 | Roman |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 30 | Bonner |
| Steve Batory | West | 32 | ST More |
| Steve Batory | West | 30 | Carroll |
| Larry Blong | West | 31 | ST More |
1968 | Art Hunter | Bonner | 31 | Neumann |
| Mike Krawczyk | Judge | 34 | McDevitt |
| Mike Krawczyk | Judge | 34 | Dougherty |
| Bob Haas | McDevitt | 51 | Ryan |
| Bob Haas | McDevitt | 37 | Kenrick |
| Hank Siemiontkowski | North | 39 | McDevitt |
| Hank Siemiontkowski | North | 31 | Kenrick |
| Mike Jones | ST More | 32 | West |
| Bob Dennis | West | 30 | Neumann |
1967 | Lou Weidner | Judge | 31 | North |
| Ron Kurtz | North | 34 | La Salle |
| Joe Hazinsky | O'Hara | 33 | West |
| Joe Hazinsky | O'Hara | 32 | Roman |
| Joe Hazinsky | O'Hara | 31 | ST More |
| Austin Quinn | O'Hara | 30 | ST More |
| Ed Dodds | St. James | 30 | Roman |
| Ron Billingslea | West | 30 | ST More |
1966 | Mike Hauer | Bonner | 32 | Roman |
| Mike Hauer | Bonner | 32 | O'Hara |
| Mike Hauer | Bonner | 30 | St. James |
| Jim Fitzgerald | Egan | 30 | Kenrick |
| Dan Kelly | McDevitt | 33 | Dougherty |
| Dan Kelly | McDevitt | 32 | La Salle |
| Bob Atene | Neumann | 31 | Roman |
| Stan Witalec | North | 36 | Dougherty |
| Steve Schaefer | Roman | 32 | Neumann |
| Nick Lombardo | St. James | 31 | Bonner |
1965 | John Carney | Egan | 30 | Kenrick |
| Joe Russell | Neumann | 35 | St. James |
| Bill Zeits | Prep | 30 | ST More |
| Dennis Malseed | St. James | 31 | O'Hara |
| Joe Hartman | ST More | 34 | St. James |
| Fran Kehoe | West | 30 | Roman |
1964 | Mike Kempski | Dougherty | 31 | McDevitt |
| Bob Walchek | North | 32 | Judge |
| Walt Bussom | Roman | 31 | Bonner |
| Jim Frick | Roman | 30 | ST More |
| Richie Berberian | West | 31 | SJ Prep |
| Richie Berberian | West | 31 | ST More |
1963 | George Smith | La Salle | 30 | Judge |
| Jim Frick | Roman | 32 | Judge |
| Ed Setaro | St. James | 33 | Bonner |
| Larry White | ST More | 30 | Neumann |
1962 | Mike Schanne | Bonner | 32 | ST More |
| Billy Oakes | Neumann | 34 | ST More |
| Tony Gielda | North | 30 | Prep |
| Tom Duff | Prep | 30 | St. James |
| Mike Maloney | St. James | 37 | Neumann |
| Frank Kehoe | West | 30 | Roman |
1961 | Bob DeFino | Bonner | 33 | Neumann |
| Butch Iancale | St. James | 30 | North |
1960 | Joe Kelly | Judge | 31 | Prep |
| Tony Mairone | North | 32 | Dougherty |
| Mike Steele | ST More | 30 | St. James |
| Jim Flavin | West | 31 | La Salle |
1959 | Jerry O'Hea | Prep | 32 | Roman |
| Tom Galia | St. James | 31 | Dougherty |
| Tom Galia | St. James | 30 | Bonner |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 38 | Bonner |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 36 | St. James |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 35 | Judge |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 34 | West |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 33 | Neumann |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 31 | La Salle |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 30 | Prep |
1958 | Bill Englesbe | Prep | 30 | ST More |
| Bill Burton | ST More | 33 | Prep |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 30 | Bonner |
| Billy Hoy | ST More | 30 | North |
| Dan Bugey | West | 30 | Neumann |
1957 | Jerry Cosgrove | La Salle | 33 | ST More |
| Nick Dolo | Roman | 30 | West |
| Ray Brown | West | 30 | Bonner |
1956 | Joe Heyer | La Salle | 49 | ST More |
| Joe Heyer | La Salle | 39 | Judge |
| Bob Craig | Neumann | 32 | ST More |
| Jim Kenny | North | 31 | Judge |
| Bobby McNeill | North | 46 | St. James |
| Ray "Butch" Linden | St. James | 33 | ST More |
1955 | Frank Delano | Prep | 30 | South |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 45 | North |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 30 | Roman |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 30 | North |
| Ed Barkett | Roman | 31 | North |
| Connie Macauley | Roman | 30 | South |
| Jim Grazione | South | 35 | Prep |
| Jim Grazione | South | 33 | St. James |
| Jim Grazione | South | 32 | Roman |
| Jim Grazione | South | 30 | North |
| Jim Grazione | South | 30 | North |
| Pat Carey | West | 47 | Roman |
1954 | Al Haeber | La Salle | 37 | Prep |
| Al Haeber | La Salle | 31 | North |
| Ray Dovell | Roman | 30 | Prep |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 40 | Roman |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 30 | North |
| Don "Squeegee" Campbell | West | 30 | Roman |
1953 | Tom Short | North | 32 | ST More |
| Joe Ryan | Prep | 34 | St. James |
| Don Cannon | ST More | 33 | Roman |
1952 | Bill Lynch | St. James | 42 | Prep |
| Bill Lynch | St. James | 31 | South |
| Bill Lynch | St. James | 31 | South |
| John "Misty" Fannon | ST More | 31 | La Salle |
| Joe Sturgis | West | 39 | Prep |
1951 | Tom Gola | La Salle | 40 | North |
| Tom Gola | La Salle | 33 | St. James |
| Bob Devenney | North | 42 | St. James | |